A true crime podcast about an unsolved murder in Aurora, Illinois
Named one of the best podcasts of 2026 by the BBC, the Irish Independent, and Podcast Review
All episodes available now.
Trailer
Jeff Signorelli was murdered in 2002 in a completely random act of violence. This podcast isn’t asking whodunnit? or how? or why? Instead, it’s asking what now?
Episode 1: It Could Be a Thick Book
Willy visits Al and Mary Ann for the first time. He learns more about his hometown than he expected.
Episode 2: The Culture of the Department
Al and Mary Ann meet with Aurora’s new chief of police, which sets the tone for their relationship with the APD.
Episode 3: Single-Issue Candidate
Al runs for city council. He finds himself up against more than his opponents in the election.
Episode 4: A Seat at the Table
A promising anti-violence program comes to Aurora. Mary Ann makes moves to keep it from falling apart.
Episode 5: Aurora Kids
Al and Mary Ann drive to the hospital to find Jeff.
Episode 6: What Now?
In a final interview with Al and Mary Ann, Willy aims to answer unresolved questions.